Tone Controls Poll (2)

Firstly yes, I think I would buy a (GSP) preamp with tone controls – emphasis, though, on the reference to GSP.

To explain briefly, I am uncertain how GSP fits into the general UK/EU audio landscape. My observation, made from the ‘frozen colonies’, would  characterize GSP as a small ‘boutique’ builder that holds to a ‘form follows function’ approach and is very focused on the musical output. With that knowledge, and having trust in Graham’s desire and ability to stay true to his reputation, a preamp with defeatable tone controls would be a non-issue for me.

I’m thinking that, regardless of their personal preference for tone controls, most of those considering a GSP purchase will most likely by familiar Graham’s ability to execute and, therefore, would not be totally put off.  And the loan program is always there to measure GSP’s success, (though sadly not for me).

Assuming no huge cost differential, I would think there would be more upside to GSP including tone controls for those who have expressed interest, and then relying on their expertise and reputation (and the loan program) to sway most of those with misgivings.

Regards,

JamesD wrote: Decisions decisions... I bet Graham is wishing he'd stuck with 'simple' phono stages ;-)

There could be a good case for employing tone controls in a preamp if it is likely that it will be used to connect a variety of sources and amplifiers.

Naim for example, build a variety of sources and ampliers. So you could argue that you will never need tone controls if using their matched components.

However, if you were a small manufacturer of a wonderfully pure preamp, it could apparently upset the balance of a very bright source or amp. In addition, DACS seem to offer oppurtunity for a huge number of input sources such as mobile phones, tablets and laptops. In such cases, tone controls would be appropriate.

The key would be to persuade the purists, that the tone controls didn't affect the sound output when switched out and didn't add too much to the overall cost.

So, I am arguing both ways. Methinks, there may be an opening for me in politics.